12axes-testTake the test
Issue · mostly Culture

Immigration

How many people should be allowed to move here?

Immigration policy is about who may enter a country, how many, and on what terms. Supporters of openness point to labor needs, new ideas, family ties and the freedom of people to seek a better life. Supporters of limits point to pressure on housing, wages and public services, to social cohesion, and to the right of a political community to decide who joins it. Most people sit between the two and argue over numbers, skills and speed rather than a total yes or no.

On the 12 Axes, all four statements move the culture axis. Welcoming newcomers and wider freedom to live and work abroad pull toward Multicultural. Cutting numbers and giving citizens priority for jobs and services pull toward National identity. The issue cuts across the usual left and right split. Business owners on the right often want more workers, while some on the left worry about wages and the strain on public services. Free movement fans and nationalists can also end up disagreeing with their own side.

The two sides

What each side argues

Open to newcomers

  • Supporters say immigrants fill job gaps, start businesses and bring new skills and ideas.
  • Supporters argue that people should be free to move for work or safety, just as goods and money do.
  • Supporters believe diverse societies are more dynamic and open.

Limit arrivals

  • Opponents say a country has the right to control who enters and how fast it changes.
  • Opponents argue that high numbers can strain housing, schools and health care, and put pressure on wages.
  • Opponents believe shared culture and trust are easier to keep when integration keeps pace with arrivals.
In the test

4 statements on immigration

  • Immigration from different cultures makes a society stronger.Agreeing moves you toward Multicultural
  • The government should reduce the number of immigrants allowed into the country.Agreeing moves you toward National identity
  • Citizens should have priority over non-citizens for jobs and public services.Agreeing moves you toward National identity
  • People should have more freedom to live and work in other countries.Agreeing moves you toward Multicultural
Answer them in the test
On the record

What politicians have said and done

At each end of Culture

People whose overall profile leans furthest each way on the axis this issue moves most. A lean on the axis is not a stance on this exact issue.

Multicultural
National identity

More culture issues

Immigration: questions

Is immigration a left or right wing issue?

It splits both camps. The left often favors openness and rights, but some on the left worry about wages and public services. The right often favors limits, but business interests may want more workers. Your place on the culture axis is a better guide to your view than a party label.

What is the difference between legal and illegal immigration?

Legal immigration follows a country's rules, such as visas, work permits or family routes. Illegal immigration means entering or staying without permission. Most debates cover both. People differ on how easy legal routes should be and on what to do about those already living in a country without status.

Does immigration help or hurt the economy?

Economists and voters disagree, and the answer depends on who arrives, what skills they have, and how well they are integrated. Supporters stress labor supply and growth. Critics stress pressure on services and low wage workers. Most agree the details of policy matter more than a simple yes or no.