12axes-testTake the test
Issue · mostly Security

Drug policy

Should drugs be legal?

Drug policy asks how the law should treat people who use drugs. One view says the criminal law is the right tool, because drugs harm users and communities, and strong penalties deter use and trafficking. Another view says adults should be free to make their own choices, and that criminalizing use fills courts and prisons, feeds illegal markets and pushes people away from help. Between them are approaches that treat use as a health problem, with treatment in place of punishment.

On the 12 Axes this issue moves the security axis. Making personal drug use legal for adults points toward the Liberty pole, while strict enforcement points toward Order. The issue cuts across left and right in a few ways. Libertarians on the right and progressives on the left often reach the same conclusion for different reasons, one stressing personal freedom and the other stressing public health and fairness. Meanwhile, some religious and traditional voters on both sides favor tough laws on moral grounds. There are also views in between, such as legal for some drugs but not others, or decriminalization without full legalization.

The two sides

What each side argues

Legalize personal use

  • Supporters of legalization argue that adults should be free to make choices about their own bodies.
  • Supporters say criminalizing users fills courts and prisons, and does little to reduce use.
  • Supporters believe legal supply would undercut criminal gangs and make drug use safer through regulation.

Keep it illegal

  • Opponents argue that drugs cause serious harm to users, families and communities, and the law should signal that.
  • Opponents say legalization could increase use, including among young people.
  • Opponents believe that strong laws help police tackle supply and keep neighborhoods safe.
In the test

The statement on drug policy

  • Possessing drugs for personal use should be legal for adults.Agreeing moves you toward Liberty
Answer them in the test
On the record

What politicians have said and done

At each end of Security

People whose overall profile leans furthest each way on the axis this issue moves most. A lean on the axis is not a stance on this exact issue.

Liberty
Order

More security issues

Drug policy: questions

What is the difference between legalization and decriminalization?

Legalization makes drug use, sale and production lawful and usually regulated. Decriminalization removes criminal penalties for personal possession but the drugs remain illegal, often with fines or referral to treatment instead. Many people support decriminalization without supporting a legal market.

Should drugs be legal?

People disagree. Supporters of legalization stress personal freedom and the failures of prohibition. Opponents stress harm to health and society. Many favor a middle route, such as treating use as a health issue while keeping trafficking illegal. The answer may also differ by drug.

Is drug legalization left or right wing?

It does not fit one side. Libertarian conservatives and progressives often support it, while traditionalists on both sides oppose it. On the 12 Axes it is measured mainly on the security axis, from Liberty to Order.