12axes-testTake the test
Mikhail Bakunin
Historical figureRussia1814-1876

Mikhail Bakunin

Revolutionary · Political writer

Russian revolutionary and the best-known 19th-century voice of collectivist anarchism, whose clash with Karl Marx split the socialist movement.

Profile on 12 axes10 of 12 documented
ECONOMYSTATESOCIETYWORLDOwnershipMarketsWelfareAuthoritySecurityStructureMoralityReligionTechnologyCultureTradeForeign
Where they stood

Mikhail Bakunin, axis by axis

  1. PublicPrivate
  2. PlannedFree

    Under his collectivism, worker associations paid for labour took the place of capitalist markets, but central state planning was rejected as well.

  3. SharedSelf-reliant
  4. DemocraticStrong leader

    He opposed all state power. Critics point out, however, that he planned secret revolutionary societies run with strict discipline.

  5. LibertyOrder
  6. LocalCentral
  7. ProgressiveTraditional
  8. SecularReligious
  9. 09TechnologyNo clear record
    EmbraceCaution

    No known position, so there is no score.

  10. MulticulturalNational identity

    He was an internationalist, but his early Pan-Slavism and his antisemitic comments about Marx and Jews are documented and widely criticised.

  11. 11TradeNo clear record
    GlobalProtected

    No known view on tariffs, so there is no score.

  12. CooperationStrength

    He was against state armies yet for insurrection and revolutionary violence, so the score reflects an internationalism hostile to the state.

2 axes have no clear record, so matching leaves them out.

Who was Mikhail Bakunin?

The noble family of Mikhail Bakunin lived at Pryamukhino in the Russian Empire. He dropped a military career to study philosophy, in Moscow first and then in Berlin. He fought in the 1848-1849 revolutions, was arrested and imprisoned, and was sent to Siberia, escaping in 1861. Once in the West he became the chief voice of anti-authoritarian socialism in the International Workingmen's Association. A bitter quarrel with Marx ended in his expulsion at the 1872 Hague Congress. Two of his major texts are God and the State and Statism and Anarchy. Bakunin died in Bern.

Political views

  • Insisted that a revolution should destroy the state, not capture it, because rule by a state always means domination.Source: plato.stanford.edu
  • Predicted that a workers' state in the Marxist mould would be run by a new elite drawn from former workers and intellectuals.Source: marxists.org
  • Held that freedom and socialism cannot be separated, and rejected liberal capitalism and authoritarian socialism alike.Source: marxists.org
  • Called for land and the means of production to belong collectively to free associations of workers.Source: marxists.org
  • Wanted a society of self-governing communes joined in a federation, organised from the base upward.Source: theanarchistlibrary.org
  • Dismissed religion and divine authority as props for political domination.Source: plato.stanford.edu

Legacy

Bakunin inspired anarchist movements in Spain, Italy, Switzerland and Latin America. In Spain they included the anarchist trade unions that counted for so much in the 1930s. Anarchists and some historians say he foresaw how a revolutionary regime could harden into a bureaucratic ruling class, a charge later aimed at the Soviet Union. Marxists called him a conspirator who broke the International in two. Liberal and conservative critics point to his support for insurrection, and historians have found antisemitic passages in his attacks on Marx. He is still read by libertarian socialists. A line from an 1842 essay, that the urge to destroy is also a creative urge, is often quoted to capture his revolutionary temper.

In their own words

“Convinced that freedom without Socialism is privilege and injustice and that Socialism without freedom is slavery and brutality.”
Federalism, Socialism, Anti-Theologism, 1867
“They will no longer represent the people, but only themselves and their claims to rulership over the people.”
Statism and Anarchy, 1873

How close are you to Mikhail Bakunin?

Take the 12 Axes test and see which historical figure is your political twin, axis by axis.

Take the test

Mikhail Bakunin: questions

Was Mikhail Bakunin an anarchist?

Yes, he is counted among the founders of modern anarchism. He wanted the state abolished and replaced by free communes and worker associations holding land and tools in common.

Why did Bakunin and Marx fall out?

Marx held that workers should take state power for a time on the road to communism. Bakunin replied that such a state would create a fresh ruling minority. The row ended in his expulsion from the International in 1872.

Did Bakunin believe in God?

No. He rejected religion and divine authority because he saw them as supports for political domination. He makes the case in God and the State.

Sources