12axes-testTake the test
James Buchanan
Historical figureUnited States1791-1868

James Buchanan

15th President of the United States (1857-1861) · U.S. Secretary of State

Pennsylvania Democrat who served as the 15th president and is often ranked among the worst, for backing Dred Scott and the Lecompton Constitution and doing little as the South seceded.

Profile on 12 axes8 of 12 documented
ECONOMYSTATESOCIETYWORLDOwnershipMarketsWelfareAuthoritySecurityStructureMoralityReligionTechnologyCultureTradeForeign
Where they stood

James Buchanan, axis by axis

  1. PublicPrivate

    Public ownership was not a live issue then. The score comes from his Democratic view that Washington should do little in the economy.

  2. PlannedFree

    A Jacksonian Democrat who resisted federal moves in the economy, even in the Panic of 1857.

  3. SharedSelf-reliant

    Washington did very little in the Panic of 1857, and there was no welfare system in his day.

  4. DemocraticStrong leader

    Gave his support to the Lecompton Constitution although few white Kansans wanted it, and pressured a Supreme Court justice to back a wide Dred Scott ruling.

  5. LibertyOrder

    Marched troops to Utah in 1857-1858 so that a federal governor could replace Brigham Young, and then pardoned settlers who accepted federal rule.

  6. LocalCentral

    Held that leaving the Union was illegal, yet Washington could not compel a state to stay. This leans local.

  7. 07MoralityNo clear record
    ProgressiveTraditional

    No stand on family life or social customs is recorded beyond the norms of his time. Left blank.

  8. 08ReligionNo clear record
    SecularReligious

    His Utah policy was about federal power, not religion itself, and no other religious programme is recorded. Left blank.

  9. 09TechnologyNo clear record
    EmbraceCaution

    No view on record, in a 19th-century setting.

  10. 10CultureNo clear record
    MulticulturalNational identity

    The sources record no stand on immigration. Left blank.

  11. GlobalProtected

    Though a Democrat, he signed the protective Morrill Tariff just before leaving office, with Pennsylvania in mind. Near the middle.

  12. CooperationStrength

    Co-wrote the Ostend Manifesto under Pierce, went on seeking Cuba as president and talked of Americans being destined to spread across the continent.

4 axes have no clear record, so matching leaves them out.

Who was James Buchanan?

James Buchanan was the son of Irish immigrants and trained as a lawyer in Pennsylvania. He then spent some forty years in public service. He sat in the House and Senate and served as minister to Russia, as Polk's secretary of state and as Pierce's minister in London. Because he was overseas during the Kansas-Nebraska fight, he avoided the blame and won the Democratic nomination in 1856, then the presidency. He hoped the Dred Scott ruling would settle the slavery question. Instead it, along with his backing of a proslavery constitution for Kansas, split his party. After Lincoln won in 1860, seven Southern states left the Union before Buchanan's term ended. He said he had no power to stop them.

Political views

  • In the 1857 Dred Scott case he urged Justice Robert Grier to side with a broad majority. The ruling said Congress had no power to ban slavery in the territories.Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • He supported Kansas entering the Union under the proslavery Lecompton Constitution, even though most white Kansans did not want it.Source: millercenter.org
  • After Lincoln's election he said he had no power to stop secession, and he did nothing to prevent it.Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • In 1857 he sent an army to the Utah Territory to install a new governor. He later offered a pardon to residents who accepted federal rule.Source: millercenter.org
  • As president he kept trying to annex Cuba, but Republican opposition in Congress ended the effort.Source: millercenter.org
  • In March 1861, near the end of his term, he signed the Morrill Tariff because it protected Pennsylvania's industries.Source: en.wikipedia.org

Legacy

Historians and ranking surveys keep placing Buchanan last or close to it. The main charge is that he failed to stop the Union breaking apart and that his policies favoured the South. Critics say his part in Dred Scott and his backing of the Lecompton Constitution, which Stephen Douglas called a fraud, angered the North and divided the Democrats. A small group of defenders says the crisis was close to impossible, that he read his powers narrowly and that he avoided a war before Lincoln took over. The Utah expedition was also criticised as costly and badly planned. Buchanan spent his last years defending what he had done.

How close are you to James Buchanan?

Take the 12 Axes test and see which historical figure is your political twin, axis by axis.

Take the test

James Buchanan: questions

Which party did James Buchanan belong to?

He was a Democrat. In 1856 he beat the Republican John C. Frémont and the Know-Nothing candidate Millard Fillmore.

How did Buchanan respond to secession?

He said secession was illegal, yet argued that Washington had no right to use force to keep a state in the Union. He took no military action, although he refused to give up Fort Sumter.

Why is James Buchanan ranked among the worst presidents?

Historians fault his pro-Southern handling of Kansas and Dred Scott. They also fault his passivity as the country fell apart in the winter of 1860-1861.

Sources