12axes-testTake the test
Irving Kristol
Historical figureUnited States1920-2009

Irving Kristol

Co-founder and co-editor of The Public Interest (1965-2002) · Founder and publisher of The National Interest (1985-2002)

Editor and essayist known as the godfather of neoconservatism, who travelled from youthful Trotskyism to defending capitalism, traditional values and a forceful American role in the world.

Profile on 12 axes10 of 12 documented
ECONOMYSTATESOCIETYWORLDOwnershipMarketsWelfareAuthoritySecurityStructureMoralityReligionTechnologyCultureTradeForeign
Where they stood

Irving Kristol, axis by axis

  1. PublicPrivate
  2. PlannedFree

    He gave capitalism two cheers for delivering wealth and freedom but held back a third, since he thought it leaves people spiritually empty. The score is pro-market but short of the maximum.

  3. SharedSelf-reliant

    He disliked most Great Society programs but accepted the narrower welfare state created under Franklin Roosevelt.

  4. DemocraticStrong leader
  5. LibertyOrder

    During the Cold War he took the view that communists did not deserve the civil rights other citizens had.

  6. LocalCentral

    He wrote that neoconservatives accept a bigger state as normal and lack Hayek's dread of serfdom, although they dislike welfare services run from the centre.

  7. ProgressiveTraditional
  8. SecularReligious

    Many neoconservatives did not practise a faith, but he described a partnership with religious traditionalists and said that economics cannot ignore moral and religious thought.

  9. 09TechnologyNo clear record
    EmbraceCaution
  10. MulticulturalNational identity
  11. 11TradeNo clear record
    GlobalProtected
  12. CooperationStrength

2 axes have no clear record, so matching leaves them out.

Who was Irving Kristol?

Irving Kristol was born in 1920 to Jewish immigrant parents in Brooklyn. He studied at the city's City College, where he joined a small Trotskyist group that opposed Stalin. He fought in Europe in the Second World War as an infantryman. Later he worked for Commentary, helped found the magazine Encounter in Britain and ran Basic Books. He started The Public Interest in 1965 to study how government programs can backfire, and The National Interest in 1985. He later lectured at NYU, wrote a regular column for the Wall Street Journal and was a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. In 2002 he was given the Presidential Medal of Freedom. He died in 2009.

Political views

  • Called neoconservatism a persuasion, not an ideology, and he defined a neoconservative with a quip: a liberal who has been mugged by reality.Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • Favoured lower tax rates to spur steady economic growth, and he saw deficits as a short-term price worth paying for it.Source: aei.org
  • Rejected most Great Society schemes, yet he could live with the smaller safety net left by the New Deal.Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • Believed government has a legitimate part to play in the quality of schools, in questions of church and state, and in controlling pornography.Source: aei.org
  • Wanted public and private institutions to foster patriotism, and warned that a world government could become a world tyranny.Source: aei.org
  • Held that America ought to defend democracies when they are attacked, including Israel, and play the leading part on the world stage.Source: aei.org
  • Ran The Public Interest as a place to show how liberal planning can produce harm nobody meant.Source: en.wikipedia.org

Legacy

Admirers say Kristol built the journals, think tanks and arguments that helped many disillusioned liberals join the conservative movement. They also credit him with promoting supply-side economics and with handing Republicans a governing outlook that tolerated a limited welfare state. In 1979 Esquire gave him the title godfather of neoconservatism. On the left, Michael Harrington used the word neoconservative as an insult, and Peter Steinfels wrote a 1979 book arguing it meant giving up on liberal reform. Traditional conservatives resented the group's rising influence, and the two camps clashed in the early 1980s when Mel Bradford's bid to lead the humanities endowment was blocked. Opponents of the 2003 Iraq War blamed neoconservative thinking for it. Encounter also drew scrutiny when its backing from the CIA came to light.

In their own words

“First, patriotism is a natural and healthy sentiment and should be encouraged by both private and public institutions.”
The Neoconservative Persuasion, The Weekly Standard, 2003

How close are you to Irving Kristol?

Take the 12 Axes test and see which historical figure is your political twin, axis by axis.

Take the test

Irving Kristol: questions

How did Irving Kristol define neoconservatism?

Kristol said it was a mood and outlook, not a fixed ideology. His famous line was that a neoconservative is a liberal mugged by reality, someone who lost faith in government schemes after seeing them fail.

Why only two cheers for capitalism?

He thought capitalism deserved credit for producing prosperity and personal freedom. He would not give it a third cheer, because he believed it fails to give people deeper meaning or shared moral values.

Was Irving Kristol a Trotskyist?

As a young man at City College he belonged to a small Trotskyist group against Stalin. He later left the left entirely, and by the 1960s and 1970s he was a leading voice of the neoconservative movement.

Sources