12axes-testTake the test

Nationalism

Also called: National movement · National self-determination

Nationalism is the belief that each nation has a right to govern itself and that loyalty to one's nation should rank high among our other loyalties.

Nationalism on 12 axes-100 to +100
ECONOMYSTATESOCIETYWORLDOwnershipMarketsWelfareAuthoritySecurityStructureMoralityReligionTechnologyCultureTradeForeign
Where it stands

Nationalism, axis by axis

  1. PublicPrivate
  2. PlannedFree

    Over time nationalist movements have supported free markets, state-led growth and socialism.

  3. SharedSelf-reliant
  4. DemocraticStrong leader

    Nationalism has gone together with free democracy and with dictatorship, so this score is a rough average of the two.

  5. LibertyOrder
  6. LocalCentral
  7. ProgressiveTraditional
  8. SecularReligious
  9. EmbraceCaution
  10. MulticulturalNational identity
  11. GlobalProtected
  12. CooperationStrength

What is Nationalism?

Nationalists see the human race as made up of peoples, and say each people deserves its own political home, most often a sovereign state. What counts as a nation varies: some mix of language, history, culture, land and a shared will to live together. Nationalists say people do best under institutions that reflect who they are. The label stretches from independence fights against empires to campaigns to guard the cultural unity of old states. So you find nationalists on the left, in the center and on the right.

Core beliefs

  • A nation is a real community and deserves respect as one.
  • A people has the right to rule itself, ideally in a state of its own.
  • Loyalty to the nation comes before loyalty to bodies above it.
  • A common language, history and culture are worth keeping alive and handing down.
  • Trade, defense and foreign relations should serve national interests.
  • Fellow citizens owe each other more than they owe strangers.

History

Most historians date nationalism's rise as a political force to the late 1700s. The American and French revolutions made the nation, not the king, the source of authority. Johann Gottfried Herder claimed that each people has a language and culture of its own. Johann Gottlieb Fichte urged Germans to unite. Giuseppe Mazzini tied Italian unity to republican democracy. During the 1800s, nationalism helped create Italy and Germany and drove independence movements in Latin America and the Balkans. After 1918 it helped break up old empires, and from 1945 it powered the end of European colonies in Asia and Africa. Later scholars, including Ernest Gellner and Benedict Anderson, asked how mass schooling and print created national feeling in the first place.

Variants

Civic nationalism builds the nation on shared citizenship and values, while ethnic nationalism builds it on descent, language or culture. Liberal nationalism pairs national feeling with individual rights. The anticolonial kind seeks freedom from foreign rule. Economic nationalism backs tariffs, support for home industry and control of key resources. Religious nationalism ties the nation to a faith. Regional or separatist nationalism seeks independence or autonomy within a larger state.

Criticisms

Liberals and cosmopolitans say nationalism splits humanity, breeds hostility to outsiders and invites discrimination against minorities. Many historians count it among the causes of both world wars and of ethnic cleansing in later conflicts. Marxists say it papers over class divisions by putting bosses and workers under one flag. Some conservatives fear that fierce national feeling can swallow religion, local custom and limits on the state. Defenders answer that nations supply the trust that democracy and welfare need, and that self-determination freed many peoples from foreign rule.

In practice

The modern world map is largely a nationalist creation. The idea of self-determination shaped the peace treaties after 1918 and appears in the United Nations Charter. Almost every state teaches a national history and backs an official language. Nationalist ideas also feed into citizenship and immigration rules, tariffs, military budgets and heritage protection. On the 12 axes the profile is strongest on Culture, toward National identity, and clearly on the Protected and Strength sides of Trade and Foreign policy.

How close are you to Nationalism?

Answer the 12 Axes test and see your match with Nationalism and 120+ other ideologies, axis by axis.

Take the test

Nationalism: questions

Is nationalism left wing or right wing?

It has been used by both. Independence movements were often on the left, while today the word is mostly tied to the right. That mix is why its economic scores on the 12 axes stay near the middle.

Nationalism vs patriotism: what is the difference?

Patriotism is affection for your country and its people. Nationalism is a political program, one that wants peoples to govern themselves and wants national identity and interests to weigh heavily in policy.

When did nationalism start?

Most scholars place the start of modern nationalism in the late eighteenth century, around the American and French revolutions. Some argue that national feeling existed earlier, but the political movement for nation states is much newer.

Further reading