12axes-testTake the test
Rosa Luxemburg
Historical figureGermany1871-1919

Rosa Luxemburg

Marxist theorist · Economist

Polish-born German Marxist who rejected both gradual reform and Bolshevik authoritarianism, and who was murdered during the January 1919 uprising in Berlin.

Profile on 12 axes11 of 12 documented
ECONOMYSTATESOCIETYWORLDOwnershipMarketsWelfareAuthoritySecurityStructureMoralityReligionTechnologyCultureTradeForeign
Where they stood

Rosa Luxemburg, axis by axis

  1. PublicPrivate
  2. PlannedFree
  3. SharedSelf-reliant
  4. DemocraticStrong leader

    Against the Bolsheviks she defended free elections, a free press and open argument. She still backed revolution and a 'dictatorship of the proletariat' that she took to mean rule by the masses.

  5. LibertyOrder
  6. LocalCentral

    She disliked Lenin's extreme party centralism, yet she also rejected federalism and national self-determination, so she lands near the centre.

  7. ProgressiveTraditional
  8. SecularReligious
  9. 09TechnologyNo clear record
    EmbraceCaution

    No known position, so there is no score.

  10. MulticulturalNational identity

    A convinced internationalist, she refused to treat Polish independence as a socialist goal. Polish nationalists and some socialists faulted her for it.

  11. GlobalProtected

    For her, tariffs were part of the contest between imperial powers. That is an analysis rather than a trade programme.

  12. CooperationStrength

One axis has no clear record, so matching leaves it out.

Who was Rosa Luxemburg?

Rosa Luxemburg came from Zamość in Russian-ruled Poland, where her family was Jewish. After studying at Zürich she moved to Germany in 1898 and soon stood out as an intellectual of the left in the Social Democratic Party (SPD), as well as in Polish social democracy. Among her best-known books are Reform or Revolution, The Mass Strike and The Accumulation of Capital. When war came in 1914 she opposed it, and she spent a large part of the war in jail. She led the Spartacus League with others and helped found the German Communist Party. In January 1919 Freikorps soldiers murdered her in Berlin.

Political views

  • Replied to Eduard Bernstein that reforms on their own could not bring about a socialist transformation.Source: marxists.org
  • Believed that spontaneous mass strikes were the best way for workers to build political power.Source: marxists.org
  • Opposed the 1914 war, and the SPD's decision to vote for war credits, and urged workers in all countries to act together.Source: marxists.org
  • Attacked Lenin's plan for a strictly centralised party led by full-time revolutionaries.Source: marxists.org
  • Welcomed the Russian Revolution, but blamed the Bolsheviks for closing down elections, the press and free assembly.Source: marxists.org
  • Saw nationalism, even the Polish kind, as a diversion from the class struggle across borders.Source: plato.stanford.edu

Legacy

Democratic socialists, council communists and some of the New Left admire Luxemburg for insisting that Marxism needs political freedom. Her sentence about the freedom of those who think differently is widely quoted. East Germany honoured her officially, but its dissidents used that same sentence in protests in 1988. Lenin called her a true revolutionary while rejecting her views on the party and on self-determination of nations. Liberal and conservative critics stress that she wanted capitalism overthrown. Polish nationalists disliked her stand against an independent Poland. The Rosa Luxemburg Foundation, close to Die Linke, carries her name, and economists and historians still discuss her writing on imperialism.

In their own words

“Freedom only for the supporters of the government, only for the members of one party, however numerous they may be, is no freedom at all. Freedom is always and exclusively freedom for the one who thinks differently.”
The Russian Revolution, chapter 6, 1918

How close are you to Rosa Luxemburg?

Take the 12 Axes test and see which historical figure is your political twin, axis by axis.

Take the test

Rosa Luxemburg: questions

Was Rosa Luxemburg a communist?

She was a revolutionary Marxist who wanted socialism to replace capitalism, and she helped found the German Communist Party in late 1918. She also condemned the Bolsheviks for denying political freedom.

How did Rosa Luxemburg die?

Freikorps soldiers murdered her in Berlin in January 1919, while the Spartacist uprising was being crushed.

What did Rosa Luxemburg disagree with Lenin about?

She backed the Russian Revolution but opposed Lenin's tightly controlled party. She thought the Bolsheviks were wrong to suppress elections and the press, and she disagreed with him on the self-determination of nations.

Sources